Pro arguments: Difference between revisions

From Independence of Québec
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Mathieugp (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Mathieugp (talk | contribs)
 
(177 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
This section gathers various links chosen by us to help visitors understand what Québec sovereignists and other independentists are fighting for. Discover the story of a very long national liberation that never ends...
This page gathers various on line documents and resources that we have chosen to help visitors understand what Québec sovereignists and other independentists are fighting for. Whenever possible, we provide English language material and we have even translated some documents ourselves for the sake of our English-speaking visitors. However, bear in mind that most of the pro-independence literature has not necessarily been translated to English. This is only the tip of the iceberg.
 
Now, be ready to discover the story of a very old national liberation movement that continues to this day.  


==Basic Notions==
==Basic Notions==


* Take some [http://www.languageguide.org/francais/ French lessons] ;-)
* Take some [http://www.languageguide.org/francais/ French lessons] on line or immerse yourself into our society by moving to Québec! ;-)
* Learn to spot a [http://www.geocities.com/safacta/fallacies.html fallacy] when you see one
* Learn to spot a [http://www.logicalfallacies.info fallacy] when you see one
* Learn of common [[Myths and fallacies about Québec|myths and fallacies]] in the Quebec debate
* Learn of common [[Myths and fallacies about Québec|myths and fallacies]] in the Quebec debate
* Have a look at [[a few important facts]] you should not miss
* Have a look at [[a few important facts]] you should not miss
* Read our answers to some [[FAQ|frequently asked questions]]
* Read our answers to some [[FAQ|frequently asked questions]]
* Learn some of the [[Key concepts to understand Quebec politics|key concepts]] in Quebec politics
* Learn some of the [[Key concepts to understand Quebec politics|key concepts]] in Quebec politics
* Read on the [[range of attitudes towards Québec]]
* The reality of the [[situation of English speakers in Québec]]
* See the other side: [[Anglophones for Québec]]
* Read some famous [[quotes]]
* Consult our [[terminology]] page
* Consult our [[terminology]] page


Québécois and Canadian intellectuals agree on the basics...
''Québécois'' and Canadian intellectuals agree on the basics...


* [http://www.cam.org/~ipso/Textes/common_declaration.htm Common Declaration of Québécois and Canadian Intellectuals], by ''Les Intellectuels pour la souveraineté''
* Read ''[[Common declaration of sovereignist and federalist intellectuals from Canada and Québec]]'', by ''Les Intellectuels pour la souveraineté''
* [http://pages.infinit.net/mseymour/apage/ap_openletter.html Open Letter in Support of Québec's Right to Self-Determination] by Michel Seymour
* Read ''[[Open letter in support of the democratic right to self-determination for Quebec|Open Letter in Support of the Democratic Right to Self-Determination for Québec]]'', by Gary Kinsman et al.


== Historical Arguments ==
== Historical Arguments ==


243 years of a just political resistance to imperialism and assimilation in the name of [[Wikipedia:Human dignity|human dignity]].
243 years of a just political resistance to [[Wikipedia:Imperialism|imperialism]] and [[Wikipedia:Cultural assimilation|assimilation]] in the name of [[Wikipedia:Human dignity|human dignity]].


===Historical Overview===
===Overview===


* Read our translation of the ''[[Political Testament of Louis-Joseph Papineau|Political Testament]]'' of Louis-Joseph Papineau
* Read the page dedicated to the [[history of our movements]]
* Read the page dedicated to the [[history of our movements]]
* Read the translation of the [[Political Testament of Louis-Joseph Papineau]]
* Discover famous [[List of people in the history of Quebec|people in the history of Québec]]
* Discover famous [[List of people in the history of Quebec|people]] in the history of Québec
* Read a few [http://english.republiquelibre.org/pdf/selected-texts-on-quebec-democracy.pdf selected texts on Québec democracy] by the ''Ministère des relations internationales'' (PDF)
* Read a few [http://english.republiquelibre.org/pdf/selected-texts-on-quebec-democracy.pdf selected texts on Québec democracy] by the ''Ministère des relations internationales'' (PDF)
* Read the section dedicated to [[other independence movements]]
* Read the section dedicated to [[other independence movements]]


===Historical Documents===
===Documents===


* 1970: The [[manifesto of the Front de libération du Québec]]
* 1970: The [[manifesto of the Front de libération du Québec|manifesto]] of the ''[[Wikipedia:Front de libération du Québec|Front de libération du Québec]]''
* 1960: The [[manifesto of the Rassemblement pour l'indépendance nationale]]
* 1960: The [[manifesto of the Rassemblement pour l'indépendance nationale|manifesto]] of the ''[[Wikipedia:Rassemblement pour l'indépendance nationale|Rassemblement pour l'indépendance nationale]]''
* 1958: The [[manifesto of the Alliance laurentienne]]
* 1958: The [[manifesto of the Alliance laurentienne|manifesto]] of the ''[[Wikipedia:Alliance laurentienne|Alliance laurentienne]]''
* 1934: The [http://www.members.tripod.com/simonlapointe/his3508/aln.html manifesto of the Action libérale nationale] by Paul Gouin (French)
* 1934: The [[Manifesto of the Action libérale nationale|manifesto]] of the ''[[Wikipedia:Action libérale nationale|Action libérale nationale]]''
* 1839: The [http://www2.marianopolis.edu/quebechistory/docs/durham/ Report on the Affairs of British North America] by the Earl of Durham
* 1867: The [[Political Testament of Louis-Joseph Papineau|Political Testament]] of [[Wikipedia:Louis-Joseph Papineau|Louis-Joseph Papineau]]
* 1838: The [[Declaration of Independence of Lower Canada]] by Robert Nelson
* 1853: An account of [[An Excursion to Canada]] by [[Wikipedia:Henry David Thoreau|Henry David Thoreau]]
* 1837: A translated excerpt of the [[manifesto of the Fils de la liberté]]
* 1839: The ''[[History of the Insurrection in Canada in refutation of the report of Lord Durham]]'' by Louis-Joseph Papineau
* 1834: The [http://www.canadiana.org/ECO/PageView/9_03428/0299?id=5453f19cc73285cb&size=3 Ninety-Two Resolutions] of the Parti patriote
* 1839: The [http://www.canadiana.org/ECO/PageView?id=cb002794415f982e&display=32374+0002 ''Report on the Affairs of British North America''] by [[Wikipedia:John Lambton, 1st Earl of Durham|John Lambton]], 1st Earl of Durham
* 1831: The [[notes of Alexis de Tocqueville in Lower Canada]]
* 1838: The ''[[Declaration of Independence of Lower Canada]]'' by Robert Nelson
* 1784: The lampoon ''Appel à la justice de l'État'' by Pierre du Calvet
* 1837: The [[Address of the Fils de la liberté of Montreal to the young people of the colonies of North America|address]] of the ''Fils de la liberté'' of Montreal to the young people of the colonies of North America
* 1775: The [http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/contcong/05-29-75.htm Letter to the Inhabitants of Canada] of the first Continental Congress
* 1837: The [[List of the public meetings held in Lower Canada between May and November 1837|resolutions]] adopted during county meetings in response to the ''Ten Resolutions''.
* 1837: John Russell's [[John Russell's Ten Resolutions|Ten Resolutions]] ultimately adopted by the British Parliament
* 1834: The [[The Ninety-Two Resolutions of the Legislative Assembly of Lower Canada|Ninety-Two Resolutions]] of the Legislative Assembly of Lower Canada
* 1831: The [[notes of Alexis de Tocqueville in Lower Canada|notes]] taken by Alexis de Tocqueville while visiting Lower Canada
* 1794: ''[[The Free French to their Canadien Brothers]]'', by [[Wikipedia:Edmond-Charles Genêt|Edmond-Charles Genêt]], Ambassador of the first [[Wikipedia:French First Republic|French Republic]] in the United States
* 1784: A ''[[System of Government for Canada]]'', a project of constitutional reform by [[Wikipedia:Pierre du Calvet|Pierre du Calvet]] and [[Wikipedia:Francis Maseres|Francis Maseres]]
* 1774: The ''[[Letter to the Inhabitants of the Province of Quebec]]'' of the [[Wikipedia:First Continental Congress|First Continental Congress]]


===Québec's Historical Demands===
===Québec's demands===
 
In the old dialectic between Québec and Ottawa, the one which started as early as 1867, successive Québec parliaments wrestled the federal executive and legislative powers to keep them out the jurisdictions which are exclusive to provinces, as per the constitutional text of law. The contemporary movement for independence, which truly took form after WWII, initiated the breaking away from this useless dialogue that, even in the best scenario imaginable, would have left Quebec with less than equality.
 
From the [http://www.saic.gouv.qc.ca/index_en.htm ''Secrétariat aux affaires intergouvernementales canadiennes''] of the Government of Québec:


* [http://www.saic.gouv.qc.ca/institutionnelles_constitutionnelles/table_matieres_en.htm Québec's Positions on Constitutional and Intergovernmental Issues from 1936 to March 2001]
* [http://www.saic.gouv.qc.ca/institutionnelles_constitutionnelles/table_matieres_en.htm Québec's Positions on Constitutional and Intergovernmental Issues from 1936 to March 2001]
Line 53: Line 63:
* [http://www.saic.gouv.qc.ca/publications/documents_inst_const/statut-pol_en.pdf Québec's Political & Constitutional Status] (PDF)
* [http://www.saic.gouv.qc.ca/publications/documents_inst_const/statut-pol_en.pdf Québec's Political & Constitutional Status] (PDF)


===Failure of Constitutional Reforms===
===Failure of constitutional reforms===
 
Understood by Quebec to be a pact between two founding peoples, the "confederation" of 1867 was not always rejected by a majority of Quebec nationalists. The failure of constitutional talks in 1971, 1982, 1989 and 1992 has pushed yet more so called "soft" nationalists to adopt the sovereignist thesis that the time has come for Quebecers to stop asking for permissions to an authority that does not respect them, draft their own constitution and assume all their responsibilities toward themselves.


* Read [http://www.bibliotheque.assnat.qc.ca/01/mono/2005/08/819576.pdf Canadian federalism and the autonomy of Québec: a historical viewpoint] by Marc Chevrier (PDF)
* Read [http://www.bibliotheque.assnat.qc.ca/01/mono/2005/08/819576.pdf Canadian federalism and the autonomy of Québec: a historical viewpoint] by Marc Chevrier (PDF)
Line 59: Line 71:
* Read on [[Institutional bilingualism]] on this site
* Read on [[Institutional bilingualism]] on this site


==Cultural Arguments==
==Linguistic & Cultural Arguments==
 
Since the 1950s, the Quebec literary and artistic community has been very engaged in the struggle for the independence of Quebec, the defence of the French language and development of Quebec's national culture. The support of talented artists and intellectuals is largely responsible for the wide support Quebec nationalism receives in the general public. You will find many writers, poets, playwrights and song writers under '''Opinions by individual militants''' just below.
 
=== The complex demolinguistic situation ===
 
To understand the desire for independence, we believe it necessary to fully comprehend the fate of Quebec French, language of the majority in Quebec, but language of a national minority inside Canada since the 1850s. Basic notions of language demographics and sociolinguistics are a must.
 
* Read ''[[The real force of French in Quebec]]'', a translation of a December 2005 article by Charles Castonguay
* Read [http://www.vigile.net/ds-lisee/docs/Langue3-2003-English.ppt ''Conference: The French fact in Québec and Canada: The Hidden Storm''] by Jean-François Lisée, a conference held at the American University Summer Institute, Washington D.C., June 2004
* Read ''[[What is the real force of attraction of French in Quebec? A critical analysis of the improvement of the situation of French observed in 2001|What is the real force of attraction of French in Quebec?]]'', a translation of a December 2001 article by Charles Castonguay
* Read ''French is on the ropes. Why won’t Ottawa admit it ?'' by Charles Castonguay, in Policy Options / Options politiques, 20, 8 : 39-50, 1999
* An good introductory read: [http://www.inroadsjournal.ca/pdfs/Inroads_8_Castonguay.pdf ''Getting the facts straight on French : Reflections following the 1996 Census''] by Charles Castonguay, in [http://www.inroadsjournal.ca/ Inroads Journal], volume 8, 1999, pages 57 to 77
* Read a [http://www.parl.gc.ca/committee/CommitteePublication.aspx?SourceId=50628 ''Transcript of a Standing Joint Commitee on Official Languages hearing''] with Charles Castonguay, recorded on April 28, 1998
 
=== Poems, songs, movies ===


* Read all our [[Translations of poems and lyrics]]
* Peek through the [http://www.independance-quebec.com/musique/liste.php?selection=aucun Independentist Music Directory] (French)
* Peek through the [http://www.independance-quebec.com/musique/liste.php?selection=aucun Independentist Music Directory] (French)
* Read some [http://membres.lycos.fr/poetesse/souvreine/quebec.html Independentist & Sovereignist Poetry] (French)
* Read some [http://membres.lycos.fr/poetesse/souvreine/quebec.html Independentist & Sovereignist Poetry] (French)
* Discover movie director [http://www.pierrefalardeau.cjb.net/ Pierre Falardeau] (French)
* The film ''[[Wikipedia:February 15, 1839|15 février 1839]]'' by movie director [http://www.pierrefalardeau.cjb.net/ Pierre Falardeau] (French)
* 1974: The political poem [http://membres.lycos.fr/poetesse/souvreine/poetes/hl/lalonde/lalonde01.html Speak White] by Michèle Lalonde
* Read the article [http://www.axess.com/users/jackr/godin.htm ''A Sovereign Presence - The poet and the politician in Gérald Godin''] by Jack M. Ruttan
* 1972: The poem [http://www3.sympatico.ca/etienne.geoffroy/alouette/flash.htm L'alouette en colère] by Félix Leclerc ( >> [[Translations of poems and lyrics|English translation]] << )
* The film [http://www.onf.ca/trouverunfilm/fichefilm.php?id=18114&v=h&lg=en ''A Song for Quebec''] by Dorothy Todd Hénaut
* 1948: The [[Refus global]] manifesto by Paul-Émile Borduas
* The film [http://www.onf.ca/trouverunfilm/fichefilm.php?id=13651&v=h&lg=en ''Two Episodes from the Life of Hubert Aquin''] by Jacques Godbout
* Read the article [http://www.axess.com/users/jackr/godin.htm A Sovereign Presence - The poet and the politician in Gérald Godin] by Jack M. Ruttan
 
* Read all our [[Translations of poems and lyrics]]
* 1972: A flash animation of the poem [http://www3.sympatico.ca/etienne.geoffroy/alouette/flash.htm ''L'alouette en colère''] by Félix Leclerc ( >> [[Translations of poems and lyrics|English translation]] << )
* 1948: Read an English translation of the ''[[Refus global Manifesto|Refus global]]'' manifesto by Paul-Émile Borduas
* 1888: Read the novel [http://www.amazon.com/Family-Without-Name-Into-Abyss/dp/1589633997 ''A Family Without a Name: Into the Abyss''], by French writer [[Wikipedia:Jules Vernes|Jules Vernes]], on the insurrections of 1837-1838
 
==Opinions by individual militants==
 
* Read [[opinions by individual militants]]
* See the list of [[books]] written by advocates of Quebec independence


==Various opinions and documents by militants==
==Opinions by militant organizations==


===St-Jean-Baptiste Society===
===St-Jean-Baptiste Society===


* Read the section dedicated to the St-Jean-Baptiste Society
The oldest patriotic institution of Quebec, the St-Jean-Baptiste Society was founded in 1834 by [[Wikipedia:Ludger Duvernay|Ludger Duvernay]].
 
* Read the section dedicated to the [[Saint-Jean-Baptiste Society]]


===Les Intellectuels pour la souveraineté (IPSO)===
===Les Intellectuels pour la souveraineté (IPSO)===


* [http://www.cam.org/~ipso/ Website of IPSO] (in French)
* [http://www.ipsoquebec.org/ Web site] of IPSO (in French)
* [http://www.cam.org/~ipso/ancien%20site/doc/objecta.html Sovereignty: A Legitimate Goal]
* ''[[Quebec Sovereignty: A Legitimate Goal]]'', 1995
* [http://www.cam.org/~ipso/ancien%20site/doc/yes.html A Yes for Change]
* ''[[A Yes for Change]]'', June 1995
 
=== Political parties ===


===Michel Seymour, philosopher===
Many political parties officially advocating a) colonial self-government vis-a-vis London, b) provincial self-government vis-a-vis Ottawa or c) the independence of Québec have been created in history. There are presently two major parties supporting independence: the Parti québécois (PQ) and Québec solidaire (QS).


* Québec Nationalism and Canadian Federalism
====Parti québécois (PQ)====
* On Redefining the Nation (PDF)
* Québec and Canada at the Crossroads: A Nation within a Nation (PDF)
* The anti-democratic drift of the federal government: A brief concerning Bill C-20
* Michel Seymour's Website


===Jean-François Lisée, journalist===
Founded in 1968, the Parti québécois still is today the main political party of Quebec advocating secession from the federal state of Canada.


* Jean-François Lisée's [http://www.vigile.net/ds-lisee/english.html texts in English]
* [http://www.pq.org Web site] of the Parti québécois
* [http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw/102-5128593-1291324?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=lisee&Go.x=0&Go.y=0&Go=Go Books] by Jean-François Lisée
* [http://www.pq.org/tmp2005/finances_english.pdf ''Budget of a sovereign Québec''], by François Legault, October 2005 (PDF)
* See our page on the [[presidents of the Parti québécois]]


===Andrée Ferretti, RIN militant and writer===
===== SPQ Libre =====


* Read [[The Parti québécois: for or against independence?]]
The SPQ Libre (Syndicalistes et progressistes pour un Québec libre) is a "political club" officially recognized by the PQ in 2006. The political stance of its member is similar to that of Québec solidaire parti members, however they have refused to completely break away from the PQ.
* Various [http://membres.lycos.fr/quebecunpays/Andree-Ferretti-Quebec-un-Pays.html texts] on the Website "Québec un pays" (French)
* More [http://www.vigile.net/auteurs/f/ferrettia.html texts] at Vigile.net (French)


===Guy Bouthillier, former SSJB President===
* [http://www.spqlibre.org/ Web site] of the SPQ Libre
* [http://www.spqlibre.org/default.aspx?page=22 ''Declaration of principles''] (French only)


* Fundamental law, or fundamental flaw? (2002)
====Bloc québécois (BQ)====
* Why does it not simply eliminate all questions on ethnic origin and religion?
* Books by Guy Bouthillier (French)


===Pierre Bourgault, former RIN president and journalist===
Founded in 1990, the Bloc québécois provides an alternative to Quebecers when voting in federal elections.


* A Radical from Quebec Passes
* [http://www.blocquebecois.org/fr/publications-english.asp Web site] of the Bloc québécois
* Books by Pierre Bourgault


===Daniel Turp, former Bloc Québécois MP and constitutionalist===
====Québec solidaire (QS)====


* Works and opinions published in English
Founded in 2006, Québec solidaire is the result of the merger of the Union des forces progressistes party and Option citoyenne movement.
* Quebec's Quest for Sovereignty and Partnership
* Québec's Right to Secessionist Self-Determination
* Don't buy Stéphane Dion's response to the secession ruling (1999)
* 1995 Project of a Sovereign Québec Constitution (French)


== Positions of political parties ==
* [http://quebecsolidaire.net Web site] of the Québec solidaire party
* [http://quebecsolidaire.net/assets/files/english/congres_de_fondation/en_projet_declaration_principes.pdf ''Declaration of principles''] (PDF)


===Parti québécois===
====Historical====


* [[Presidents of the Parti québécois]]
* [[Wikipedia:Parti canadien|Parti canadien]] or [[Wikipedia:Parti patriote|Parti patriote]] (1790s to 1837)
* 5 questions and answers to understand why the Parti québécois wants Québec to become a sovereign country
* [[Wikipedia:Parti rouge|Parti démocratique]] or [[Wikipedia:Parti rouge|Parti rouge]] (1848 to 1850s)
* [[Wikipedia:Parti républicain du Québec|Parti républicain du Québec]] (1962 to 1964)
* [[Wikipedia:Rassemblement pour l'indépendance nationale|Rassemblement pour l'indépendance nationale]] (1964 to 1968)
* [[Wikipedia:Ralliement national|Ralliement national]] (1965 to 1968)
* [[Wikipedia:Parti indépendantiste|Parti indépendantiste]] (1985 to 1990)
* [[Wikipedia:Union des forces progressistes|Union des forces progressistes]] (2002 to 2006)


===Québec solidaire===
== See also ==


* [http://quebecsolidaire.net Website of the Québec solidaire party]
* [[List of organizations advocating the independence of Quebec]]
* [http://quebecsolidaire.net/assets/files/english/congres_de_fondation/en_projet_declaration_principes.pdf Declaration of principles] (PDF)
* Read on the [[range of attitudes towards Québec]]
* See a list of [[List of translations done for this site|all our translations]]
* Read some famous [[quotes]] by various contemporary and historical figures
* [http://www.marxists.org/history/canada/quebec/ ''Quebec's Struggle for Nationhood''] on Maxists.org

Latest revision as of 23:04, 2 November 2010

This page gathers various on line documents and resources that we have chosen to help visitors understand what Québec sovereignists and other independentists are fighting for. Whenever possible, we provide English language material and we have even translated some documents ourselves for the sake of our English-speaking visitors. However, bear in mind that most of the pro-independence literature has not necessarily been translated to English. This is only the tip of the iceberg.

Now, be ready to discover the story of a very old national liberation movement that continues to this day.

Basic Notions

Québécois and Canadian intellectuals agree on the basics...

Historical Arguments

243 years of a just political resistance to imperialism and assimilation in the name of human dignity.

Overview

Documents

Québec's demands

In the old dialectic between Québec and Ottawa, the one which started as early as 1867, successive Québec parliaments wrestled the federal executive and legislative powers to keep them out the jurisdictions which are exclusive to provinces, as per the constitutional text of law. The contemporary movement for independence, which truly took form after WWII, initiated the breaking away from this useless dialogue that, even in the best scenario imaginable, would have left Quebec with less than equality.

From the Secrétariat aux affaires intergouvernementales canadiennes of the Government of Québec:

Failure of constitutional reforms

Understood by Quebec to be a pact between two founding peoples, the "confederation" of 1867 was not always rejected by a majority of Quebec nationalists. The failure of constitutional talks in 1971, 1982, 1989 and 1992 has pushed yet more so called "soft" nationalists to adopt the sovereignist thesis that the time has come for Quebecers to stop asking for permissions to an authority that does not respect them, draft their own constitution and assume all their responsibilities toward themselves.

Linguistic & Cultural Arguments

Since the 1950s, the Quebec literary and artistic community has been very engaged in the struggle for the independence of Quebec, the defence of the French language and development of Quebec's national culture. The support of talented artists and intellectuals is largely responsible for the wide support Quebec nationalism receives in the general public. You will find many writers, poets, playwrights and song writers under Opinions by individual militants just below.

The complex demolinguistic situation

To understand the desire for independence, we believe it necessary to fully comprehend the fate of Quebec French, language of the majority in Quebec, but language of a national minority inside Canada since the 1850s. Basic notions of language demographics and sociolinguistics are a must.

Poems, songs, movies

Opinions by individual militants

Opinions by militant organizations

St-Jean-Baptiste Society

The oldest patriotic institution of Quebec, the St-Jean-Baptiste Society was founded in 1834 by Ludger Duvernay.

Les Intellectuels pour la souveraineté (IPSO)

Political parties

Many political parties officially advocating a) colonial self-government vis-a-vis London, b) provincial self-government vis-a-vis Ottawa or c) the independence of Québec have been created in history. There are presently two major parties supporting independence: the Parti québécois (PQ) and Québec solidaire (QS).

Parti québécois (PQ)

Founded in 1968, the Parti québécois still is today the main political party of Quebec advocating secession from the federal state of Canada.

SPQ Libre

The SPQ Libre (Syndicalistes et progressistes pour un Québec libre) is a "political club" officially recognized by the PQ in 2006. The political stance of its member is similar to that of Québec solidaire parti members, however they have refused to completely break away from the PQ.

Bloc québécois (BQ)

Founded in 1990, the Bloc québécois provides an alternative to Quebecers when voting in federal elections.

Québec solidaire (QS)

Founded in 2006, Québec solidaire is the result of the merger of the Union des forces progressistes party and Option citoyenne movement.

Historical

See also